Rediscovering Empathy and Rekindling Hope
In 1989, at Chitrakoot Inter College, Mahendra, a Hindu, Yasin, a Muslim, and Vishal, a Christian became fast friends. Mahendra and Yasin shared a room because Yasin faced difficulties in renting one as he was a Muslim. In that shared room, they navigated the delicate frictions of difference. They learnt to live together despite differences in food habits and other things. At first, Mahendra, a strict vegetarian, was aghast that Yasin had cooked meat. Then he insisted that cooking meat was okay, but the kitchen had to be cleaned thoroughly afterwards. Slowly barriers melted, and Mahendra began eating eggs.
After college, life swept them down separate paths. Decades rolled
by, and as the friends drifted apart into the quiet routines of work and
family, the outside world grew increasingly polarized. Mahendra started feeling
guilty that he had not kept in touch with his close friend over the years. He
wondered how his friend felt in this changing social landscape. Mahendra felt a
restless urge to reconnect, but still he hesitated.
Through conversations with friends in the Humqadam
initiative, Mahendra finally sought out Yasin in 2021. The moment they met,
decades of silence and societal division dissolved. They shared their lives in
the years in between, about their spouses and their children, about their joys
and their sorrows. It did not take long for Vishal’s name to crop up in their
conversation. They met up with him, and soon the three friends were together
again. Today their bond has strengthened. Their families now celebrate
festivals, attend weddings, and support each other through life's hardships. Their
friendship had survived not because the world had become kinder, but because
they chose not to let fear decide who belonged in their lives.
In the heart of Bundelkhand’s Jalaun district, the village of Lohai
was a place where invisible walls ran deep. Caste divisions dictated daily
life, and strict segregation kept communities apart. But during the Navdurga
festival, a local man named Jagpal saw a quiet stage in the afternoon sun and
envisioned something radical: a stage where everyone belonged.
He proposed a community singing competition for women and girls. It
was a beautiful, ambitious dream, but the hurdles were immediate. The festival
stage sat squarely in the upper-caste neighbourhood, managed entirely by them.
Yet, through gentle persuasion, Jagpal convinced the management committee to
open the space.
On the day of the event, the square filled with an unprecedented
crowd—Dalit, OBC, upper-caste, and the village’s lone Muslim family sitting
side by side.
The air was thick with anticipation as three generations of women
took the stage to sing of faith, social change, and old folk traditions. But
the old world didn't vanish easily. Early in the program, the management
committee quietly withheld the traditional dhol (drum) and jhika
(cymbals) from the lower-caste teams.
A small murmur of disappointment ran through the crowd. Soon voices
from different communities rose. The musical instruments had to be available to
all participants. Each group deserved equal opportunities. Someone suggested
that the upper caste women could talk to the management committee. They too had
been waiting for this day and wouldn’t let their menfolk ruin their fun. Finally,
the committee relented. The instruments were handed over, and the music
extravaganza started.
When the last notes faded, the judges faced a delicate crisis: the
upper-caste team had not performed well, and declaring a lower-caste winner
threatened to shatter the fragile peace. Thinking quickly, Jagpal turned to the
crowd, proposing an audience poll.
When the call came, hands shot into the air across all divides. It
wasn't about caste anymore; it was about honouring the music and each other.
The crowd chose fairness, and the village celebrated as one.
The melody of that afternoon didn't fade when the stage was
dismantled. A new harmony had taken root in Lohai. Weeks later, looking at a
severely damaged village road that needed urgent repairs, the residents didn't
retreat into their separate enclaves. Instead, Dalit, OBC, upper-caste, and
Muslim neighbours walked shoulder-to-shoulder to the local authorities, signing
their names to a single, joint petition.
In Lohai, music didn't just bridge a historic divide; it taught a
village that when they raise their voices together, they can rebuild their
world. But why did Jagpal think of doing this music festival? Jagpal was part
of a small group of rural activists who were concerned about the increasing
social polarisation in the world around. Initially, he felt angry, sad, and
helpless at the same time. He felt paralysed with doubt. What if I am also
targeted if I say something? He then joined a small group of friends who shared
the same doubts, the same hesitation, and the same helplessness. Slowly they
shared their fears, rekindled hope and started taking actions like the one
Jagpal did in his village or Mahendra in his life. Humqadam was the name
they gave their shared journey of courage, hope and action.
Humqadam is the story of quiet
resistance. In the villages of Uttar Pradesh, where slowly growing suspicion
and hatred were tearing communities apart. A group of veteran social activists was
deeply disturbed and hesitant at the same time. They faced fear, not just
around them, but within. But once they came together, they responded not with retreat
but with hope: rebuilding trust and drawing strength from forgotten traditions
of coexistence.
For years, these activists had worked with men to promote gender
equality. But this alone did not help against religious polarisation. With
deeper analysis, they realised that work on gender equality alone was not
enough when communities themselves were being pulled apart by fear and mistrust.
Humqadam was a quiet attempt to find
ways to respond to these ruptures. Seven community-based activists turned inward to examine
their own journeys, seeking new frameworks for understanding and new ways of
action. In the politically sensitive and socially complex landscapes of Uttar
Pradesh’s Purvanchal and Bundelkhand regions, it was a quiet collective effort
to resist social division. Ten veteran activists—seven Hindus and three Muslims
aged between 40 and 60 - drew upon the state's traditional, shared cultural
heritage (Sajhi Virasat) as an antidote to rising religious polarization,
hostility and aggression.
When the initiative began in early 2022, there were deep anxieties
among the community-based colleagues. Decades of grassroots work were being
undone by a sharp spike in identity politics, online trolling, and fake news.
The social landscape had profoundly transformed. Communities were
fracturing along religious and caste lines, giving rise to aggressive
identity-driven groups. Muslim communities faced heightened anxiety. Muslim men
were being stereotyped as criminals and anti-socials. As many of the younger
men from both Hindu and Muslim communities were outside for work, the older men
of the community controlled the social and gender narrative. Government
functionaries, who were earlier very cooperative had changed, and partisan
politics increasingly influenced public services. Activists, both Hindu and
Muslim, had stopped raising everyday deprivations faced by poor Muslims because
they faced backlash if they did so.
Through their conversations with each other, they realized that
standard development programs focused strictly on women’s development and
rights had inadvertently ignored some other trends in society. Many young men,
angry, unemployed and constantly exposed to political propaganda, were becoming
increasingly vulnerable to ideas building hatred and suspicion. Widespread
government welfare distribution had created a mindset of beholden-ness towards
the government. Their earlier approach where they created a sense of ‘citizenship’
demanding rights and services was no longer viable. They had to find new ways
to deal with this reality.
Through several rounds of conversations, they realised that there
were several practices and spaces in and around the villages where they worked
where both Hindus and Muslims took part with equal enthusiasm.
It began when the colleague from Jaunpur mentioned Ghazi Miyan kibarat, a month-long festival that took place in the summer months in
several districts of UP. Both Hindus and Muslims take part in the processions
and fairs that take place on this occasion. On hearing this story, one Hindu colleague
from Azamgarh recalled there was a well-known close to his village. He
sheepishly confessed that though he had visited the village several times, he
had yet to go to the dargah. He invited all the others to his village to learn more
about it.
This visit to
the Kichchaucha Sharif Sufi dargah in Ambedkar Nagar was an eyeopener to
the Hindu colleagues. The welcome they received from the Mazār authorities, who
had been informed beforehand, surprised them. It was in a small village, but
thousands of Hindu and Muslim devotees were milling around. People had come from
all over the country seeking solace and healing.
Once they had witnessed that ordinary people from both communities
still lived and celebrated together, many other stories came tumbling out.
The colleague from Varanasi recalled a person called Jhulan Prasad.
He ran a sweet shop named 'Rajshree Sweets' in a busy marketplace and close to
a mosque. Several of the shopkeepers in the market were Muslims, and they were
his friends. During the month of Ramzan, Jhulan Prasad started distributing pakora,
chole, and sweets to his friends as they returned from their Friday
evening namaaz. Soon many more namaazis started coming, and it
became known as Jhulan Prasad ka Iftar. His grandsons run the shop today,
but this tradition continues.
Colleagues started documenting such shared traditions and
relationships in their own communities. They realised that Hindu and Muslims
living in the same village took part in each other’s family occasions and
festivals, though this was coming down. Muslim characters even acted in Ramlila,
and Hindus took part in Moharram processions. While rural artisans were mostly
Muslim, many of their clients were Hindus. And there was often a long-term
client-provider relationship that ran for generations. Friends from both
communities supported each other in agricultural activities and also ran
businesses together. Muslim artisans made Khadaus (wooden slippers) for
Brahmins of Varanasi in Jaunpur. People drank tea and gossiped together in teashops,
but slowly these were being segregated by religion.
Once they witnessed these living traditions, some still robust and
others that were fading, they decided it was time to start small initiatives
that could bring people together. A simple decision was to have joint
celebrations for festivals. They started with modest joint Diwali celebrations
and Iftar parties. These were quite successful and were encouraged. When Muslim
women said that they would take part in Holi, but only if there were no colours
thrown at them, they celebrated Holi with multi-coloured petals–Phoolon ki
Holi was the name given. The Muslim women were thrilled that their wishes were
respected. People slowly started renewing friendships and inviting and going to
each other’s family celebrations like marriages, naam-karans (naming ceremony
of babies) and funerals.
By the end of the two-and-a-half-year the Humqadam collective
successfully pioneered a model for repairing relationships damaged by fear and
hostility. Moving past their initial despair, they had not only regained hope
but discovered a new way to work. They learnt that facts and logic were not
enough to dispel deep-seated anti-Muslim myths. Instead, sharing and celebrating
were more successful in bringing people together. It allowed caring and empathy
to grow instead of indifference and hate.
A question worth mulling over is why Humqadam worked? How did it
succeed in places where religious polarisation was so deep that even senior
development workers hesitated to raise any concern about Muslims; where Muslims
had become withdrawn; old community relationships were now riven by distances;
where social media was relentlessly spreading myths, misinformation, and fake
news, and deepening social divides.
All members of the Humqadam collective were part of the community,
and these communities had long histories of living together. Also, these
communities belonged to similar caste groups and shared similar socio- economic
realities. This allowed the use of traditional symbols and histories to rebuild
solidarity. Through their efforts, they fostered human connections outside of
party politics. Bringing people together for festivals and celebrations and minor
acts of sharing helped build trust, cement friendships, and strengthen relationships.
People who felt isolated and frightened found new friends. Those who were
previously uncomfortable but silent now expressed themselves openly.
Many of us today live with a similar unease.
Friendships have become cautious. Family conversations are more contested.
People often remain silent, not because they agree with hatred, but because
they fear conflict, isolation, or being targeted themselves. Over time, this
silence creates distance. And distance slowly makes suspicion feel normal.
Humqadam did not begin with grand political
strategies or dramatic acts of resistance. It began with something smaller and
more fragile: people deciding not to withdraw from one another. A visit to an
old friend; a shared festival; a meal eaten together; a conversation that might
otherwise never have happened. These small acts did not change the world
overnight. But they changed the emotional atmosphere around the people
involved. Fear slowly gave way to familiarity. Hesitation gave way to trust.
Like Mahendra reaching out to Yasin after decades of silence, our
first step may simply be to recover an old relationship or build a new one. Perhaps that is how change begins — not in committees,
courts, elections, or television debates, but in the courage to rebuild
ordinary human relationships before apathy and fear replace trust altogether.

Wonderful
ReplyDeleteRecovering old relationships, as you rightly mention is the need of the hour. The new ones can follow! The fractures are too deep , and the common folk dont seem to bother about the complexities, for them it's a simple life, like it used to be...
ReplyDeleteSo nice and touchy event
ReplyDelete